Why is Alabama the most hated team in college football?

Last year, a survey found the Alabama Crimson Tide was the most hated team in college football, we try to explain just why Alabama football is so hated

Why is Alabama the most hated team in college football?
Why is Alabama the most hated team in college football?

The Alabama Crimson Tide washes over all of its opponents at some time or another. The history books prove it. Alabama is a team that has had a strong legacy of coaches and players with a history of winning, and its current dominance doesn’t show any sign of stopping. With 15 national championship wins the Crimson Tide is one of the leaders of the pack when it comes to football. The Alabama football team also boasts 28 conference championships spaced among eight coaches. They also have a wide variety of Bowl game wins with trophies from Rose, Sugar, Cotton and Orange Bowls in the trophy case.

The University of Alabama has had a lot of famous players too. Names like Joe Namath, Ozzie Newsome, Bart Starr, Don Hutson and Kenny Stabler are just a fraction of the legendary names to don the uniform for the Alabama Crimson Tide. Among the famous players and coaches there are 24 (23 if you don’t count Alabama tackle Frank Howard who was inducted as a coach for Clemson) that have made the college football hall of fame. Many Alabama football players have continued on to the NFL and seven of them have ended up in the NFL Hall of Fame.

Alabama is the most hated team in college football because of its history of winning

A survey found that many fans hate Alabama football. When you drill down into the data, Alabama is hated because Alabama wins. The hatred extends from two very dominant periods led by two very dominant coaches. While Alabama coaches Wallace Wade and Frank Thomas were winners, they never generated the hatred of Coach Paul W. “Bear” Bryant and Nick Saban.
[table id=5 /]

In the 1970s the Crimson Tide flooded college football. They are considered to be one of the most dominant teams of the era and it is perhaps one of the most dominant dynasties of all time. Again Alabama football won three national championships but they also took home eight Southeastern conference titles. Alabama finished ranked #2 in 1971, #4 in 1972, #1 in 1973, #2 in 1974, #3 in 1975, #9 in 1976, #2 in 1977, #1 in 1978, and #1 in 1979. Each of those corresponded with a season of 10-plus victories. The team closed the decade in the midst of a 28 game winning streak that began Oct. 30, 1978, and ended Nov. 1, 1980. The decade included back-to-back undefeated regular seasons in 1973 and 1974.

The 1970 SEC dominance is one of the key reasons for regional resentment of the Alabama Crimson Tide. It was the fecklessness of Auburn’s coaching during the late 1970s and early 1980s that prompted the arrival of Pat Dye and a reversal of Auburn’s historical mediocrity.

Bear Bryant finished his career with 292 career wins at SEC schools between his time at Alabama and Kentucky with 159 wins in conference play.

The Colossus of Tuscaloosa: Nick Saban on historic run at Alabama

Colossus_of_Rhodes
The current coach Nick Saban is one of the most polarizing figures since he returned to college football. Yet, he stands astride college football like a colossus–dwarfing all other coaches and their accomplishments. Since 2008, he has claimed three undisputed national titles, three SEC championships and posted records of 12-2, 14-0, 10-3, 12-1, 13-1, 11-2, 12-2. Saban and Alabama have lost 11 games since 2008 with five of those losses to teams that either won the national championship or played in the national championship game.

Nick Saban’s record stands at 177-59-1 for .749 winning percentage with 134 wins while at SEC schools. His conference record is an impressive 86-24 for a .782 winning percentage in SEC play.

At the end of 2014, the SEC broke down the entire SEC’s winning percentages since 2009. In that time, Alabama has won 9 games more than its closets rival, LSU. Check out the chart for a helpful visual look:
[table id=6 /]

Saban’s run included an historic first–Alabama won its first Heisman Trophy when Mark Ingram claimed the prize in 2009. It was an historic anomaly that until then, despite all the famous names and hall of famer players, Alabama never had a player win the individual award.

Ultimately, Alabama’s record of success spans each era of college football, but it was (and is) the dominance of two of the greatest coaches of all time that really made Alabama into the most hated team in college football.

7 Comments

Add Yours
  1. 1
    Hunter Ford

    There have been 7 Alabama national championships in my lifetime. My dad has been around to see 10.

    My grandfather, rest his soul, never got to see Saban coach at Alabama, but He saw Thomas, Wade and Bryant.

    It’s great to be in the Crimson Tide family!!

    Others are just jealous and envious. Non-Alabama fans hate Alabama for the same reasons some people hate The New York Yankees, or the New England Patriots,

    Sustained success breeds contempt from outsiders!

  2. 2
    Buck Holter

    It isn’t the winning itself that makes the masses hate Alabama football. It’s the attitude of Alabama football fans when they do win that is such a turn-off.

    • 3
      Capstone Report

      I’ve always wondered if maybe it was the attitude of Alabama fans when they lose that was a big turnoff to rivals.

      I remember back when all the Memphis stuff was unfolding and one UT booster told the story of how Logan Young got pissed about Peyton Manning leading the UT band after a big win in Birmingham and how he yelled about it at Roy Adams. Adams then made it his mission to go after Young and that sparked a lot of bad blood between UT and UA.

      • 4
        Hunter Ford

        I will admit, Alabama fans can be poor winners and sore losers.

        I went to the Alabama-Kentucky basketball game this year. I went to the Bryant Museum before the game, and a lot of Kentucky fans were their taking it all in.

        They seemed impressed. They also were taking in some of the Kentucky era Bryant stuff.

        Then Kentucky fans are to basketball what Alabama fans are to Football.

        Still think the main thing people hate us for is all the championship and bowl trophies and all the tradition we sometimes (just sometimes) throw in their faces.

        Especially if we lose. “Well ya’ll won today, but how many crystal ball you got in YOUR MUSEUM? Oh yeah! Your trophies wouldn’t fit in fish aquarium! RTR

    • 5
      Billy

      What “attitude” would you prefer we have? Lemme explain somethin’ t’ ya there, sporty: Alabama fans will NEVER know how to lose! Sore loser…, you’re danged right! We will never accept “excuses” for someone failing to do their best. We believe that every player plays up to his potential, no one should be able to beat an Alabama football team.

      When you look at the history of winning that IS Alabama’s, pressing for excellence should be, and is, expected. You, who know how to lose “gracefully”, we will gladly beat the brakes off of you, and give you as much practice (at losing) hat you need!

  3. 7
    Why is Alabama the most hated team in college football? : BamaFootball4Life

    […] The University of Alabama has had a lot of famous players too. Names like Joe Namath, Ozzie Newsome, Bart Starr, Don Hutson and Kenny Stabler are just a fraction of the legendary names to don the uniform for the Alabama Crimson Tide. Among the famous players and coaches there are 24 (23 if you don’t count Alabama tackle Frank Howard who was inducted as a coach for Clemson) that have made the college football hall of fame. Many Alabama football players have continued on to the NFL and seven of them have ended up in the NFL Hall of Fame. Alabama is the most hated team in college football because of its history of winning. [More] […]

Comments are closed.